Vital vs Serum: Which Wavetable Synth Is Right for You?

Choosing between Vital and Serum? Here's what you need to know:

• Vital: Free to $80, 3 oscillators, beginner-friendly
• Serum: $189, 2 oscillators, industry standard

Quick comparison:

Vital is great if you're new to wavetable synthesis or on a budget. It's got a modern interface and an extra oscillator for complex sounds.

Serum is the go-to for pros. It's been around longer, has tons of presets, video tutorials, and is a studio staple.

Related video from YouTube

Main Features

Vital and Serum pack a punch when it comes to wavetable synthesis. Let's break down how they compare:

Vital boasts three oscillators plus a sampler, while Serum offers two oscillators and a sampler. That extra oscillator in Vital? It's a game-changer for complex sound design.

Layout and Controls

Vital's interface is a visual feast. Every tweak you make comes to life on screen, making it a breeze for wavetable newbies. Serum? It's got that clean, pro look that's been setting the standard since 2014.

Oscillator Features

These synths handle wavetables differently:

• Vital: FM synthesis is its playground. Want OSC3 to modulate OSC1? Go for it. Need precise pitch control? You've got it.
• Serum: It's more straightforward. You get a sub oscillator, but you can't fine-tune its pitch modulation like in Vital.

Filter Types

Vital takes the lead here with two independent filters. Serum? Just one. That extra filter in Vital opens up a world of sound sculpting possibilities.

Modulation Tools

Both synths are modulation powerhouses, but they're not twins:

• Vital: Packs an extra envelope and visual feedback that makes complex routing a breeze.
• Serum: Solid modulation options, but one less envelope to play with.

Built-in Effects

"The only thing where Serum excels is its built-in effects."

This quote hits the nail on the head. Serum's effects are top-notch, refined over years of pro use.

Here's a quick comparison:

Sound Design Options

Wavetable Editing

Vital and Serum take different paths when it comes to wavetable manipulation. Vital's "Draw" tool lets you create custom wavetables from scratch. It also has a cool text-to-speech feature for making wavetables.

"If you really want to get into the nitty-gritty of sound design, check out Vital synth's wavetable editor. To access it, simply click on the 'Draw' tool." - Simon, Author of the Vital Synth Guide

Serum, on the other hand, lets you turn images into wavetables. Pretty neat, right? Both synths are great at wavetable editing, but Vital's free version gives you 25 wavetables, while Serum comes with 144.

Spectral Tools

Vital has this Random Modulation Generator that can spice up your sounds in unexpected ways. It's great for making evolving textures and patterns. For example, you can make weird reverb textures by freezing the chorus frequency and randomly tweaking other settings.

Serum focuses on clear, precise spectral manipulation. Its fancy noise generator is perfect for creating atmospheric sounds and adding texture to your tracks.

Sound Quality

These synths sound quite different from each other. Vital, released in 2020, sounds more natural. It's great for making organic pads and evolving soundscapes.

Serum, around since 2014, is known for its super clear, crisp sound. It's a favorite in electronic music where you need that punch and definition.

Technical Performance

CPU Load

Serum and Vital handle processing power differently. Serum is generally easier on the CPU for simple patches but can get hungry with complex sounds. A super saw patch with 2 oscillators and 8-voice unison in Serum can push CPU usage up to 30% on an i7 processor.

"Most CPU complaints I have found first and foremost come from heavy voice count compounded by not watching poly limits sensibly." - Steve Duda, Xfer Records

Vital's performance is tied to its graphics processing. Users have found that running 6 Vital tracks uses only 7% CPU, but opening the GUI can spike usage to 30-40%. A workaround: switching to Intel graphics can drop CPU load from 23% to 12-15% in Studio One.

Working with DAWs

DAWs handle these synths differently. In Reaper, CPU usage is about 35% at 4.27GHz with minimal audio dropouts. Cubase 13 Pro is more efficient at 19% CPU usage with ASIOGUARD on, but turning it off spikes usage to 40% with noticeable glitches.

Studio One v5 hits a sweet spot, running at 23% CPU usage at 4.35GHz. The trick? Set dropout protection to minimum for smooth playback. Both synths play nice with major DAWs, but Vital's modern architecture includes vector intrinsics for better performance.

"There isn't a synth that is fully optimized. A majority of the big names like Serum, Sylenth1, and Vital come close." - Plugin Developer

Want the best results with either synth? Keep an eye on your oversampling settings. For Serum, stick to 2x oversampling for normal oscillators. With Vital, think about using different oversampling settings for real-time play versus rendering.

sbb-itb-30ee575

Price and Value

Cost Options

Vital and Serum take different paths when it comes to pricing. Serum keeps it simple with a one-time $189 fee for the full package. Vital, on the other hand, gives you options.

Here's the breakdown:

Vital's free version is fully functional. It's a great way to dip your toes into wavetable synthesis without spending a dime.

Want to spread out your payments? Serum offers a rent-to-own option through Splice for $10/month. Vital's $5 monthly subscription comes with a twist - you get store credit.

Extra Content

But there's more to consider than just the synth itself.

Vital's free version gives you the basics - wavetables to create sounds, but no presets. Upgrade to Plus ($25) and you'll get a decent preset collection. Go Pro ($80) and you'll unlock 400 presets, new skins, and community perks like faster support.

"Vital offers an extremely powerful and unique synthesizer and plugin for any DAW, and it's incredible price point and feature set make it a no brainer for any upcoming or professional producer." - Joe Caputo, Electronic Music Production Instructor

Vital's subscription is pretty clever. You get monthly store credit, exclusive content packs, and first dibs on new features. The best part? Everything you buy with your credit is yours to keep, even if you cancel.

Want even more sounds? Check out the vital synth directory, it's packed with community-made presets, skins, and wavetables - some free, some paid.

User Experience

Getting Started

Vital and Serum offer different paths for newcomers to wavetable synthesis. Vital's interface is more beginner-friendly, with a clear, colorful layout that makes sound design concepts easier to grasp.

"If you are new to Sound Design and Wavetable Synths, Vital is the place to start." - John at Ra Sharpness, YouTube

Vital's visual feedback is a game-changer. When you tweak filters or modulate parameters, you see the changes happening right before your eyes. It's like having a sound design teacher built into the synth.

Serum, on the other hand, is the old pro. It's been the industry standard for years, but it's not as easy to pick up. Many users say they spent more time figuring out Serum's workflow at first compared to Vital.

Help and Resources

Both synths have their strengths when it comes to learning materials. Serum's been around longer, so there's a ton of tutorials and preset packs out there. But Vital's growing community is creating its own buzz.

The Vital Discord server is like a 24/7 sound design workshop. Users share tips and help each other out all the time. And here's a twist: Vital's free version only comes with 75 presets. That might sound like a downside, but it's actually a plus for learning:

"If you are trying to learn a synthesizer or create original sounds, presets might slow or hinder the process." - Joe Caputo, Electronic Music Production Instructor

Vital also offers hands-on learning with practical sound design examples. You can learn to create chill plucks, layered pads, moody reese basses, and bouncy techno bass sounds.

One user put it this way:

"Vital is just close enough to Serum that you can follow along the huge amount of tutorials on YouTube, but just different enough that you have to get the concept of the tweak without going into robot mode and just doing what you're told by the video."

Vital's free version includes a cool text-to-wavetable feature with 5 daily prompts. Pro users get unlimited access. It's a modern way to learn wavetable synthesis through experimentation.

Best Uses

Making Electronic Music

Serum and Vital shine in different areas of electronic music production. Serum's been around for a decade, making it a go-to in pro studios. It's especially popular for genres that need clean, high-quality sounds. With over 450 presets, it's got plenty of radio-ready tones right out of the box.

Vital brings some new tricks to the table. It's got an extra oscillator and some fancy spectral tools. This makes it great for experimental stuff and complex sound design. Its modern setup lets you create sounds that older wavetable synths just couldn't pull off.

Sound Design

For sound design, each synth has its own perks. Vital's extra oscillator and spectral shaping tools open up new creative doors. Plus, it shows you visually how your tweaks affect the sound, which is pretty cool.

"Vital offers an extremely powerful and unique synthesizer and plugin for any DAW, and it's incredible price point and feature set make it a no brainer for any upcoming or professional producer." - Joe Caputo, Electronic Music Production Instructor

Serum's still the go-to for precise, reliable sound design in pro setups. It's got tons of third-party presets and wavetables, which is great when you're on a tight deadline for commercial work.

Playing Live

When it comes to live shows, both synths have their strengths. Vital can be CPU intensive, something to keep in mind for complex live sets where you're running multiple synths at once. The free version has all the essentials, which is perfect if you're a performer on a budget.

Serum's rock-solid and has a proven track record, making it a favorite for big live productions. It needs more processing power, but its reliability and huge preset library make it a safe bet for pro live shows.

Conclusion

Vital and Serum are both top-notch wavetable synths, but they shine in different ways.

Serum costs $189 and comes with 450+ presets. It's a go-to for pro studios and big projects. Why? It's been around longer and has a ton of third-party presets.

Vital shakes things up with flexible pricing. You can start for free or go up to $80 for the Pro version. The free version isn't shabby - you get 75 presets and 25 wavetables.

So, who should pick what?

Go for Vital if you:

• Want to dip your toes into wavetable synthesis
• Need something that won't break the bank
• Like having an extra oscillator to play with

Stick with Serum if you:

• Want access to loads of presets
• Need something rock-solid for big projects
• Love to get deep with modulation

"Vital offers almost all of the features found in Serum, with an additional fully featured oscillator as well as a built-in sampler, which can double as a noise generator." - Produce Like A Pro

Vital's free version is great for beginners or those watching their wallet. The Pro version packs a punch at less than half of Serum's price, including preset bundles and regular updates.

But don't count Serum out. It's still an industry standard with tons of third-party support and a solid reputation in pro studios.

Related posts

• Free Synth Face-Off: How Vital Synth Redefines Expectations
• 5 Reasons Vital Synth Is the Best Free Synth for Sound Design